I previously reviewed Captain America: Brave New World during its theatrical run. This analysis focuses specifically on the UHD release and the experience of a second viewing.
The Value of Re-watching Films
Revisiting a film is an experience I consistently value. The tension inherent in the conclusion of Se7en remains palpable, even with foreknowledge of the ending. Recent screenings of Alien and Aliens – films with which I am intimately familiar – on the big screen felt like fresh discoveries. The evolution from VHS in 4:3 aspect ratio to today’s pristine 4K resolution represents a significant technological leap that may be lost on some contemporary viewers. In my opinion, a quality film warrants multiple viewings, whereas a poorly executed film is often a waste of time – though exceptions exist.
Second Viewing: Initial Impressions Revisited
Upon inserting the UHD disc, I anticipated a more positive experience. However, after approximately twenty minutes, I found myself strangely disengaged. The pacing, character development, and overall atmosphere felt deficient. There was a palpable sense that the production lacked energy. A particular issue, more apparent during this viewing, was the portrayal of Sam Wilson as possessing capabilities beyond those of a non-super soldier. The scene in which he deflects a blow from Red Hulk using a flagpole now ranks as a prime contender for Marvel’s most illogical moments, rivaling the sequence in Iron Man 2 where Happy carelessly runs over the legs of the (completely human) villain Ivan Vanko in a car, without causing any visible harm.
The Absence of Grit
Sam Wilson traverses the film seemingly unaffected by exertion, lacking any visible sweat or dirt. After recently re-watching Alien and Aliens, the relative absence of “physical reality” – such as grime and perspiration – in contemporary films was particularly noticeable. This could be attributed to the cost associated with maintaining consistent makeup and continuity, or perhaps interference with the creation of digital doubles. It is likely a combination of factors. While seemingly minor, this detail impacts the believability and grounded nature of the cinematic experience.
UHD Release: Technical Excellence
Unfortunately, Captain America: Brave New World did not improve upon a second viewing; in fact, my assessment diminished. However, the UHD release surpasses expectations. The film, captured using Arri Alexa cameras and finished with a 4K digital intermediate, offers exceptional sharpness and detail. Skin textures and costume details are rendered with impressive clarity, and the inclusion of HDR10 and Dolby Vision results in deep, vibrant colors and rich black levels.
The Dolby Atmos audio track is equally impressive. The soundscape creates an immersive experience, utilizing height channels effectively during flight sequences and explosions. Dialogue is clear and well-balanced, and the subwoofer provides ample low-end reinforcement without overpowering the mix.
Extras: Largely Perfunctory, but with Potential
The supplemental materials consist primarily of promotional content lacking substantive value. The blooper reel mirrors the film’s shortcomings in terms of inspiration, but the commentary track offers a glimmer of hope. While I have yet to listen to it in its entirety, I anticipate a candid discussion regarding the numerous alterations the film underwent, particularly given the presence of a character in the blooper scenes wearing a costume absent from the final cut.
Summary: Strong Technical Release for a Weak Film
I had hoped that Captain America – Brave New World would improve upon a second viewing, but the opposite occurred; my assessment of the film declined. Fortunately, the UHD release excels on all technical fronts. The exceptional picture and sound quality make it a worthwhile option for showcasing home theater systems, despite the film’s inherent shortcomings. The climactic battle at sea is visually and aurally engaging, representing perhaps the only instance where the film achieves its potential.
SF Anytime provided review copies for this analysis. The provision of materials does not influence our editorial independence; our reviews are conducted objectively with the reader and consumer as the primary focus.
