The original Thor film, directed by Kenneth Branagh, adeptly balanced grand spectacle with relatable human elements. In contrast, Thor: The Dark World, helmed by Game of Thrones director Alan Taylor, presents a different set of challenges. While Taylor’s visual style is undeniably sleek and possesses a more grounded aesthetic, the sequel falters in delivering the heart and humor that made its predecessor successful, resulting in a somewhat underwhelming experience.
The potential of Patty Jenkins (Wonder Woman)’s vision for this film remains a tantalizing “what if.” Her direction would likely have provided a more substantial role for Natalie Portman, both in this film and subsequent installments. Portman reportedly considered withdrawing from Thor: The Dark World when Jenkins’ departure became apparent, but contractual obligations prevented her from doing so. Speculation suggests Portman will return in the upcoming fourth film, Thor: Love and Thunder, slated for release in 2021, where she is also expected to wield Mjolnir.
Thor: The Dark World ultimately struggles with a disjointed narrative and a lack of clear direction. Despite a plethora of events unfolding, the film lacks significant impact. Earth faces a cataclysmic threat, yet the absence of the other Avengers, or even explicit mentions of them, diminishes the film’s connection to the broader MCU.
A key strength of the film lies in the dynamic between Chris Hemsworth’s Thor and Tom Hiddleston’s Loki. Their complex relationship, a blend of fraternal affection and animosity, provides compelling moments as Loki’s true allegiances remain ambiguous. Rene Russo’s portrayal of Thor’s mother, Frigga, is also a notable highlight.
The UHD edition, however, stands out as a showcase of exceptional audio-visual quality, exhibiting reference-level picture and sound. While some earlier Marvel Ultra HD releases have presented certain technical imperfections, this edition is notably free of such issues. The supplemental materials, mirroring the quality seen in Ant-Man, are comprehensive and well-produced. Unfortunately, these extras are sourced from the original Blu-ray release six years prior, indicating a potential decline in the creation of new bonus content.
In conclusion, while this may not be one of the strongest entries in the MCU, it avoids the pitfalls of films like Captain America: Civil War. It offers an adequate level of entertainment, and this fine UHD edition elevates it to a qualified recommendation.
